.COM Identity Crisis
Mark Jeffries, CTO Fasthosts Internet Ltd,
highlights the issue of online identity,
and seeks to know whether an owner’s
personal online image can conflict with
and damage their business.
IN THIS AGE we live in of social networking, blogging
and online forums, the issue of online identity has never
been so important. In the business world, there have
been several high-profile examples of where individuals
have made a negative impact upon a large corporation
via their personal online material. However, it appears
that personal online identity is now also a risk to the
everyday small business.
A study commissioned by Fasthosts found that
over two thirds of British business owners (67 per cent)
admit to now having concerns that how they appear
online could have a negative effect on their business.
While publishing material online is highly popular
and enjoyable, some 95 per cent of those surveyed
recognised that the online image it creates for an
individual owner can have an impact upon their business.
People don’t hesitate to put up information about
others on sites like Facebook, and don’t think about any
consequences this may have. The same survey of 540
British businesses found that 78 per cent of business
owners believed there to be personal material related to
them on the internet, and 43 per cent admitted to anxiety
that material posted online by friends or partners could
have a negative effect on their business affairs.
RESEARCH ENGINES
Significantly, the level of concern on the issue of online
material appears to mirror how heavily business owners
themselves now use the web for researching each other.
The survey revealed that one in five owners routinely
‘Google’ for personal material on rival owners and 48 per
cent judge personal online material to be representative
of a business person overall. The need for prudence
when publishing personal material can be seen from the
swiftness with which proprietors judge those they see
online. Also significantly, 66 per cent of owners surveyed
have made a judgment on at least one business contact
based solely on their online personal material. At least 48
per cent of owners surveyed believe that it is possible to
make a reliable overall assessment of a person from their
personal online material.
For the web designer, the issue of a client’s personal
identity can be potentially crippling to an online project.
There is clearly no worse scenario than having developed
a great web presence for a business only to have it
eclipsed by unfavourable personal material such as
photos, blog entries and Facebook profiles.
Businesses are increasingly seeking an integrated
approach for all their online activity. The web designer
is nowadays expected to provide strategic advice, and
today this may inevitably involve a client’s personal
media, too. So how should you approach the problem?
The potential impact on sales revenue is key. Significantly,
86 per cent of owners surveyed suspected that there
could be a link between a proprietor’s unfavourable
personal online material and a decrease in sales revenue.
The extent of alarm varied, though, with 48 per cent
viewing this to be a "significant" risk, and 46 per cent
recognising a "small" risk.
DAMAGE LIMITATION
The challenge that web designers have now is how
to take counsel on personal online identity without
scaring a client or making them disillusioned with the
web. Perhaps most significant of all the research, over
three quarters of all the business owners asked believed
that if the right balance was struck, then their personal
online identity could be used to positively impact their
business, with one in five strongly believing this to be
the case. Designers and web consultants should be
advised nowadays to arm their clients with guidelines
and a blogging strategy for using their personal web
presence in order to complement, rather than hinder,
their business ventures.
Perhaps the crux of the issue with personal online
identity is the level of control available. While social
networks offer the greatest degree of credibility and
perhaps fun, they are by nature less manageable than
a dedicated personal website. Indeed, another recent
survey of 300 people who publish their own personal
websites, as opposed to just social networking, found
that 84 per cent of those believed this offered more
control over their online image, and 79 per cent of
personal website owners were happy to recommend the
tool as a means of creating or modifying an individual’s
online image or identity.
Indeed, personal online identity comprises an
opportunity for web designers to extend their remit
beyond just the regular business brief. If web designers
can apply their experience to a client’s personal online
material, there can be great scope for synergies between
the business and the owner. Proper personal websites,
while requiring more work, offer individuals a platform
on which to publish socially and creatively but in a more
controlled, balanced way. In relation to social networks,
68 per cent of personal site owners surveyed valued their
own sites as allowing more creativity and only 26 per
cent suspected that a social networking page could be
potentially more communicative.
A personal site with well-balanced content could
be the best tactic to neutralise unfavourable personal
material posted online by others. Now there is the
need for clients to regularly perform an analysis of their
personal online material as well as their business material.
The responsibility lies with web design pros to advise
their clients on managing the personal and professional
aspects of publishing on the web. Web pros should seize
upon this business issue and make it work for them.
With the right approach, business owners can present
their personal online material in a way that won’t
compromise their business activities. Research highlights
that personal websites in particular appear to offer a high
level of control over online image, and can allow this to
be modified effectively.